A change of Lagarde

On 1 November 2019, Mario Draghi will step down as President of the European Central Bank (ECB) and hand the reigns to the first woman to take on the role: former French economy, finance and industry minister and Chairman of the IMF, Christine Lagarde.

Within a month of taking up his role in November 2011, Draghi oversaw a 489 billion euro, three-year loan program (quantitative easing) from the ECB to European banks. A couple of months later, he initiated a second larger round and, in July 2012, in the midst of the European Sovereign Debt Crisis, he promised to “do whatever it takes to preserve the euro”.

Dubbed ‘Super Mario’ ever since, Draghi will be remembered favourably by some: the euro is still here, European unemployment has fallen and the economy has muddled along.

Others say that his policies have failed and that Europe is in danger of ‘Japanification’ – entering into a prolonged deflationary period of stagnant growth.

But what has his reign resulted in for investors?

European stock market returns

The MSCI Europe ex UK is up 120.55%* since he became President of the ECB. This is significantly more than the FTSE 100 (81.96%*), but less than half the gains of the US stock market (the S&P 500 is up 241.58%*).

Actively-managed funds and trusts have fared significantly better. Cream of the crop has been Jupiter European Opportunities Trust, managed by Alexander Darwall. It has returned 252.36%* during Draghi’s reign. It is followed in second place by Jupiter European, now run by Mark Nicholls, which has returned 215.31%*. Barings Europe Select, which invests in smaller companies, is in third place with returns of 210.07%*.

Top ten Elite Rated European equity funds and trusts

PositionFund namePercentage returns*
1Jupiter European Opportunities252.36%
2Jupiter European215.31%
3Barings Europe Select210.07%
4BlackRock European Dynamic193.20%
5Marlborough European Multi-Cap176.15%
6T. Rowe Price European Smaller Companies Equity175.57%
7BlackRock Continental European Income164.07%
8Janus Henderson European Focus158.75%
9Threadneedle European Select154.43%
10CRUX European Special Situations153.33%

Bond market returns

Draghi’s monetary policy during his tenure also led to the ECB buying 90% of newly issued European government bonds over a four-year period. However, drastic action was required: the yield on the 10-year Greek government bond, for example, peaked at 36.7%** during the European Sovereign Debt Crisis and has fallen to 1.3%*** today.

Indeed, some $13 trillion of European government bonds now have negative yields – the ECB and other investors are effectively paying for the privilege of lending money to European governments. Jim Leaviss, manager of newly Elite Rated M&G Global Macro Bond fund talked to us about this recently.

But the fall in yields has led to extraordinary returns for bond holders over Draghi’s tenure. On aggregate, European government bonds have returned 110.12%^ – just 10% less than the equity market.

So what does the future hold?

The team behind TwentyFour Dynamic Bond fund believe that monetary policy in the Eurozone seems to be at, or at least very close to, its limits for the time being. They said: “Draghi’s final message could not have been clearer to Europe’s finance ministers: fiscal easing [lowering of taxes, etc] and structural reforms are needed for growth and inflation prospects to improve. The ball is firmly in the court of Eurozone politicians.”

The region is also very linked to global trade and the US/China trade wars – not to mention Trump’s threat to set his sights on Europe next – are not helping.

But Europe is a huge place, with many world-class companies, so finding investment opportunities is never difficult – even in the toughest of environments.

Christine Lagarde is unlikely to bring a major shift in stance to the ECB. She has previously expressed the view that negative interest rates in Europe and Japan were net positives for the global economy and, with this mind, she will most likely be a cautious governor who should be seen as fairly positive for investors.

There is also the fact that that a politician at the helm of the ECB may be just what is needed at a time when other politicians need to be corralled into making fiscal changes to keep European economies afloat.


*Source: FE Analytics, total returns in sterling, 1 November 2011 to 23 October 2019
**Source: Investing.com Greece 10 year bond yield, 1 November 2011
***Source: Investing.com Greece 10 year bond yield, 1 October 2019
^Source: FE Analytics, total returns in sterling, using the FTSE European Government Bond 10+ years index, 1 November 2011 to 23 October 2019

This article is provided for information only. The views of the author and any people quoted are their own and do not constitute financial advice. The content is not intended to be a personal recommendation to buy or sell any fund or trust, or to adopt a particular investment strategy. However, the knowledge that professional analysts have analysed a fund or trust in depth before assigning them a rating can be a valuable additional filter for anyone looking to make their own decisions. Past performance is not a reliable guide to future returns. Market and exchange-rate movements may cause the value of investments to go down as well as up. Yields will fluctuate and so income from investments is variable and not guaranteed. You may not get back the amount originally invested. Tax treatment depends of your individual circumstances and may be subject to change in the future. If you are unsure about the suitability of any investment you should seek professional advice. Whilst FundCalibre provides product information, guidance and fund research we cannot know which of these products or funds, if any, are suitable for your particular circumstances and must leave that judgement to you. Before you make any investment decision, make sure you’re comfortable and fully understand the risks. Further information can be found on Elite Rated funds by simply clicking on the name highlighted in the article.